Jiggin' Johnsons 2" Crappie Mayhem – Build Your Own Baits

$4.89
Bulk Pricing:

Below are the available bulk discount rates for each individual item when you purchase a certain amount

  • Buy 10 - 24 and get 10% off
  • Buy 25 - 49 and get 20% off
  • Buy 50 or above and get 30% off
Current Stock:
Secure Checkout Fast Shipping Satisfaction Guaranteed
Adding to cart… The item has been added
(No reviews yet)
Want something already on the shelf that can ship today?

Check out Jesse's ready-to-ship Mayhem baits: one-offs, experimental colors, overruns, and special batches already poured and ready to go.

Shop Ready-to-Ship Specials Same-day dispatch depends on Jesse's shipping days and order cutoff.
Jiggin' Johnsons · 2" Crappie Mayhem Series

Your crappie bait. Your colors. Your kind of Mayhem.

Ever wish you could take the tail from one bait, the body color from another, and throw in just the right glitter? That's exactly why Jesse created the Crappie Mayhem Series.

Instead of settling for somebody else's favorite combination, you build your own 2-inch crappie soft plastic. Choose from five different tail profiles, select your grub body color, pick a contrasting or matching tail color, add glitter if you want it, and finish with your choice of scent. Jesse pours your custom combination.

Go natural, go bright, match your favorite forage, or come up with something nobody else has in the tackle box. There's no single right way to build Mayhem.

Five tail profiles Choose the look and movement that fit how you fish.
Make the colors yours Mix body and tail colors, glitter, and scent.
Build multiple bags Design different combinations and take advantage of bulk savings.
Choosing your tail style

Five tails. Five different approaches.

The body may be the same, but the tail changes the presentation. Some profiles are better suited to a quiet, subtle approach. Others provide more movement when you want fish to notice your bait. Here's where we'd start with each one.

Split-tail action

Mayhem Cricket

The Cricket's two long, separated tail appendages give it a distinctive profile. Those flexible arms can respond independently to small rod movements, making this an interesting choice when you want action without constantly moving the bait forward.

Where to try it: Vertical jigging around brush piles, dock posts, and suspended crappie. Start with short lifts and pauses, allowing the twin tails to move as the bait settles.
Baitfish profile

Mayhem Minnow

The Minnow has a streamlined, forked-tail appearance that lends itself to a more restrained baitfish presentation. When crappie are focused on small minnows and shad, this is a good place to start.

Where to try it: Clear water, suspended schools, and fish feeding on young baitfish. Try a slow, steady swim, a controlled fall, or gentle twitches on a light jig head.
Swimming presentation

Mayhem Paddler

The Paddler's broad tail is designed around the idea of a more noticeable swimming action. It's a useful option when you want a compact bait that can attract attention during a moving presentation.

Where to try it: Swimming along weed edges, around docks, or across open-water crappie schools. Start with a steady retrieve and adjust speed until the tail works the way you want.
Subtle finesse profile

Mayhem Baller

The Baller has a slender tail ending in a rounded tip. Its compact profile makes it worth experimenting with when fish are inspecting a bait closely and you don't want a large, aggressive tail.

Where to try it: Slow vertical presentations, light jigging, and pressured crappie. Try small shakes, short hops, and longer pauses before increasing the action.
Curly-tail movement

Mayhem Twister

The Twister's curved tail gives it a different look from the other four profiles. A curly tail can create visible movement during a slow swim or falling presentation, making it a natural choice when you want a little more action.

Where to try it: Searching for active crappie, slow-rolling over cover, or swimming through schools. It's also worth trying on a lift-and-fall retrieve when fish need a little extra encouragement.
Not sure which tail to start with?

Try the Minnow for a natural baitfish look, the Cricket or Baller for more controlled presentations, and the Paddler or Twister when you're looking for swimming action. And don't be afraid to experiment. Finding the combination the fish want is half the fun.

Make it yours

Build a color combination that fits your water.

With 15 grub body colors and 10 tail colors, you can go with a natural, understated look or put together a high-visibility combination for stained water and low-light conditions.

Choose from 32 glitter options, or leave the glitter out entirely. Glitter can add flash and contrast to your bait, but sometimes a simple two-color combination is exactly what you want. You also have the option to add scent to your custom pour.

The live preview lets you explore combinations before you add them to your cart. Actual poured colors and glitter appearance may vary slightly from the on-screen illustration.

Frequently asked questions

Good things to know before you build.

Can I order several different designs?

Yes. Create a bag, add it to the cart, and keep designing. You can mix tail profiles, colors, glitter, scent, and package sizes.

What package sizes are available?

Choose 30 or 60 baits per bag. Each bag counts toward the Mayhem bulk savings thresholds shown in the builder.

Can I mix 30-count and 60-count bags?

Yes. Both package sizes count toward the same bag-based bulk savings thresholds. Final pricing is calculated in the store cart.

Does adding scent change the color?

Scent may slightly affect the finished plastic color. The builder preview is an illustration of your choices rather than a photograph of the finished pour.

Are these already made?

No. Build Your Own Mayhem baits are custom poured according to your selections. Jesse's ready-to-ship specials are offered separately for customers who prefer an already finished batch.